1892 - 1894 Andrew Swartz
1894 - 1897 W. Elmer Bailey
1897 - 1898 W.A. Hauck
1898 - 1899 Amos Evans
1899 - 1900 W.W. Sherrick
1900 - 1901 H.V. Summers
1901 - 1902 P.E. Smoke
1902 - 1906 J.W. Schweisberger
1906 - 1907 W.S. Harpster
1907 - 1909 C.F.M. Green
1909 - 1912 W.E. Bailey
1912 - 1915 P.F. DeVaux
1915 - 1918 H.D. Schultz
1918 - 1920 Charles L. Kern
1920 - 1922 I.H. Amore
1922 - 1924 A.J. Foreman
1924 - 1926 A.G. Tozer
1926 - 1928 L.H. Naumann
1928 - 1931 O.D. Myers
1931 - 1932 E.D. Paulin
1932 - 1933 W.R. Shisler
1933 - 1934 Chester H. Kern
1934 - 1936 N.W. Sager
1936 - 1939 Roy B. Leedy
1939 - 1948 B.L. Lee
1948 - 1951 W.B. Smith
1951 - 1953 S.L. Shockey
1953 - 1954 M.R. Frey
1954 - 1959 Walter Marks
1959 - 1961 Charles W. Cory
1961 - 1965 Robert A. Jones
1965 - 1970 Robert E. Klingel
1970 - 1973 Russell T. Panico, Sr.
1973 - 1978 Hubert A. Boles
1978 - 1984 Richard C. Adams, Jr.
1984 - 1988 Larry Johnson
1988 - 1990 Mary Thoburn Tame
1990 - 1991 David W. Davis, Sr.
1991 - 1999 Brett A. Kelly
1999 - 2005 Paul W. Goetz
2005 - 2007 James R. Sharrett, Senior Pastor
2005 - 2007 Cynthia Morrison, Associate Pastor
2007 - 2008 Debra S. Ketcham
2008 - 2015 Penny Magee
2015 - 2019 Karen L. Farr
2019 - 2021 Kevin S. Wilcox
2022 - Present Loran L. Miracle II